![[background image] of sea landscape (for a maritime service)](https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/68519729b16b09b1c70802eb/68a240331ae614368ca14211_Preservative%20Hero.png)
Preservatives might not be the most romantic part of skincare formulation, but they’re one of the most misunderstood and one of the most important.
In the world of DIY skincare, it’s easy to fall in love with raw butters, lush oils, and fragrant botanicals. But once water enters the picture, so does the need for protection. That’s where preservatives come in: not as something to fear, but as a tool to keep your creations safe, stable, and effective.
What Are Preservatives, Really?
A preservative is an ingredient added to a formulation to prevent the growth of bacteria, mold, and yeast. These microbes thrive in water, and without a preservative, a water-containing product (like a lotion or toner) can become contaminated quickly, even if it looks and smells fine.
Preservatives help:
- Extend shelf life
- Protect against microbial growth
- Keep your product safe for use over time
They’re not meant to alter your product’s performance—they’re there for protection.
Do All Products Need a Preservative?
No, but many do. Here’s a simple breakdown:
✅ Products that contain water (hydrosols, aloe vera, teas, juices): Must have a preservative.
❌ Anhydrous (oil-only) products: Don’t require a preservative but can benefit from antioxidants to extend shelf life.
✅ Products exposed to water during use (like scrubs in jars): Consider using a preservative or choose packaging that limits water exposure.
Even when preservatives aren’t required, smart formulation choices help keep your product safe.
Preservatives vs. Antioxidants
These two are often confused:
- Preservatives inhibit microbial growth (bacteria, mold, yeast)
- Antioxidants delay oxidation (rancidity) in oils and butters
For example, vitamin E is an antioxidant not a preservative. It helps extend the life of oils but doesn’t protect against contamination.
A well-formulated product may contain both.
Beginner-Friendly, Broad-Spectrum Options
Not all preservatives are synthetic, and not all are broad-spectrum (meaning they protect against bacteria, yeast, and mold, not just one type of microbe). We favor preservatives that align with natural standards and transparent sourcing, ensuring your blends remain both safe and true to their botanical roots. The options below are considered safe and effective when used correctly.
- Geogard® ECT / Preservative ECO
- INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Salicylic Acid, Glycerin, Sorbic Acid
- Usage: 0.6–1%
- pH Range: 3–8
- ECOCERT/COSMOS-approved
- Leucidal® SF Complete
- INCI: Lactobacillus Ferment (plus other fermented ingredients)
- Usage: 2–4%
- pH Range: 3-8
- Pros: Mild and good for sensitive skin
- Cons: Less effective against mold unless combined with other preservatives
- Germall Plus
- INCI: Propylene Glycol (or Glycerin), Diazolidinyl Urea, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate
- Usage: 0.1–0.5%
- pH Range: 3-8
- Not considered natural, but highly effective at low usage rates
- Optiphen Plus
- INCI: Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Sorbic Acid
- Usage: 0.75–1.5%
- pH Range: 4-8
- Works well in emulsions and is considered easy to use
Always follow manufacturer guidelines for usage rates and pH requirements.
Adjusting pH for Preservative Effectiveness
Each preservative has an optimal pH range where it remains active and effective. If your formulation’s pH falls outside that range, the preservative may lose its ability to protect against microbes even if used at the correct percentage.
How to check and adjust pH:
- Test your pH. Use a calibrated pH meter or quality pH strips. If your product is thick (like a cream), dilute a small sample in an equal amount of distilled water for an accurate reading.
- Adjust gradually.
- To lower pH (make more acidic): Add a few drops of a 10% citric acid solution (1 g citric acid + 9 g distilled water). Stir and retest before adding more.
- To raise pH (make more alkaline): Add a few drops of a 10% sodium bicarbonate solution. Mix well and retest.
- Recheck after adding your preservative. Some preservatives can slightly shift pH, so test again to confirm the final formula stays within the effective range (for example, 3–8 for Leucidal SF Complete).
Pro Tip: Always make pH adjustments in small increments, keeping detailed formulation notes. Once balanced, record your final pH for future batches.
Factors That Affect Preservation
Even the best preservative can fail if the product isn’t formulated or stored correctly. Consider:
- Water activity: More water = higher risk
- pH: Preservatives only work in certain pH ranges
- Storage: Heat and light can degrade preservation
- Packaging: Airtight or airless containers reduce contamination
- Formulation technique: Clean tools and proper sanitization matter
Common Misconceptions
Can essential oils act as preservatives?
No. While they have antimicrobial properties, they aren’t consistent or strong enough to be relied on.
Can I use vinegar as a preservative?
No. Vinegar is acidic but does not provide broad-spectrum protection.
What if I don’t use a preservative?
Without it, water-based products can spoil quickly—even without visible signs. Contaminated products may lead to irritation, breakouts, or infections.
Do I need lab testing?
In professional settings, a preservative efficacy test (PET) is ideal. For home formulators, follow best practices: use clean tools, sterile packaging, and when in doubt, err on the side of safety and add a preservative..
When Can You Skip a Preservative?
You may choose to skip it if:
- Your product is 100% oil-based
- It’s single-use or used within a few days
- You refrigerate and use quickly
Still, label it with a date and avoid contaminating it during use.
Final Thoughts
Preservatives aren’t the enemy, they’re a form of care. They allow you to confidently share your blends, use them over time, and protect your skin and others’. Thoughtful formulation includes thoughtful preservation.
At Root & Ritual, we believe natural skincare should be safe, effective, and joyful. And sometimes, the most caring thing you can add to your blend is a bit of protection.
Next in the Series — How to Customize a Base Recipe: Building Confidence in the Blend