Storage, Containers & Preservatives: How to Keep Your Creations Fresh

Even the most beautifully formulated balm or serum can fall short if not stored correctly. Preservation, whether through the right container, proper storage practices, or the thoughtful use of actual preservatives, ensures your DIY skincare remains safe and effective for as long as possible.

This guide will help you understand what kinds of containers to use, how to extend shelf life naturally, and when and how to use preservatives in your formulations.

‍

Why Proper Storage Matters

Handmade products, especially those without commercial preservatives, are more sensitive to time, light, air, and moisture. How you store your creations can dramatically impact:

Texture and consistency
Scent retention
Safety and microbial growth
Overall shelf life

Whether your goal is a few weeks of personal use or long-term gifting or selling, storage is your first line of defense against spoilage.

‍

Choosing the Right Containers

Your container does more than hold your product, it protects it.

Best Materials

Glass (amber or cobalt): Ideal for oils, serums, and balms. Offers protection from light and doesn’t leach into formulas.
Metal (tin or aluminum): Great for solid balms and butters. Lightweight and reusable.
PET or HDPE plastic: Less preferred, but can be useful for shower-safe or travel products. Choose BPA-free if possible.

Avoid When Possible

Reused food containers that can’t be fully sterilized
Wide-mouth containers for products that will be repeatedly exposed to water or direct contact

Functionality Tips

Use dropper bottles for oils and serums to avoid contamination
Use pump bottles for lotions or emulsions to minimize air exposure
Use spatulas to scoop balms instead of fingers

‍

Shelf Life by Product Type

Here are general shelf life guidelines when using clean technique and omitting added preservatives:

Anhydrous formulations (no water): 3–12 months
Emulsions (water + oil): 1–2 weeks (refrigerated)
Water-based formulations only: A few days (refrigerated)

These timelines assume:

You’ve used fresh, high-quality ingredients
The product is stored in a cool, dark place
Tools and containers were sanitized prior to use

‍

Temperature, Light & Air

Heat speeds oxidation and can degrade delicate ingredients like essential oils or plant extracts. Light, especially UV, can trigger rancidity in oils. And air exposure introduces bacteria and breaks down certain ingredients over time.

To extend shelf life:

Store in cool, dark places
Use airtight containers
Avoid introducing water or dirty fingers into the product

If your product changes color, smell, or texture significantly, it’s best to discontinue use.

‍

Natural Preservation Strategies (Without Added Preservatives)

If you prefer to formulate without commercial preservatives, here are ways to reduce risk:

Stick to anhydrous (oil-based) formulations
Use antioxidants like vitamin E to slow oxidation
Add essential oils with mild antimicrobial properties (e.g., tea tree, lavender), but note they are not broad-spectrum preservatives
Package in small batches to use up quickly
Store in the refrigerator when appropriate

Important: These methods help extend shelf life but do not protect against all forms of microbial contamination, especially in products that contain water.

‍

When to Use Preservatives

Any formulation that contains water (including aloe, hydrosols, teas, or honey) is at risk of bacterial, mold, and yeast growth even if it looks and smells fine.

If your product includes water and:

Will be stored for more than a few days
Will be shared, gifted, or sold
Will be used in a bathroom (exposed to heat and moisture)

…then it must be properly preserved.

‍

Beginner-Friendly Preservatives

These broad-spectrum, water-soluble preservatives are generally considered safe and easy to work with:

Geogard® ECT / Preservative ECO
- INCI: Benzyl Alcohol, Salicylic Acid, Glycerin, Sorbic Acid
- Usage: 0.6–1%
- pH Range: 3–8
- ECOCERT/COSMOS-approved
Leucidal® SF Complete
- INCI: Lactobacillus Ferment (plus other fermented ingredients)
- Usage: 2–4%
- pH Range: 3-8
- Pros: Mild and good for sensitive skin
- Less effective against mold unless combined with other preservatives
Germall Plus
- INCI: Propylene Glycol (or Glycerin), Diazolidinyl Urea, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate
- Usage: 0.1–0.5%
- pH Range: 3-8
- Not considered natural, but highly effective at low usage rates
Optiphen Plus
- INCI: Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Sorbic Acid
- Usage: 0.75–1.5%
- pH Range: 4-8
- Works well in emulsions and is considered easy to use

Always check usage rates and compatibility with your specific formula’s pH and structure.

Tip: Preservatives should be added during the cool-down phase, usually below 100°F (38°C), and mixed thoroughly.

Note: Manufacturer guidelines may differ slightly depending on batch composition or supplier. Always follow the specific product instructions provided by your preservative supplier if they differ from what’s listed here or elsewhere on this site.

‍

Do You Need a Preservative for Oil-Based Products?

No, but… oil-based products are still vulnerable to oxidation (rancidity), which is different from microbial spoilage. Oxidation shortens shelf life and alters scent, color, and skin feel.

Protect oil-based products by:

Adding vitamin E (tocopherol) at 0.5%–1%
Storing in amber jars away from light and heat
Using fresh, cold-pressed oils with a long shelf life

‍

Final Thoughts

Preserving your work is part of honoring the ritual. As you refine your formulation practice, understanding preservation becomes as essential as choosing the right ingredients. Whether that means choosing a beautiful violet glass bottle to shield your serum or learning when and how to include a preservative, this step helps your skincare creations remain safe and vibrant.

Your formulations are an act of care. Let your storage and preservation reflect that same intentionality.

‍

Next in the Series — Scent & Soul: Selecting Scents for Mood and Skin Type